Uncategorized September 12, 2025

How Mortgage Rates Are Determined (and Why They Don’t Always Follow the Fed)

Every time the Federal Reserve makes a move, headlines explode—and so do conversations about how it impacts mortgages here in Lancaster. Naturally, the question we hear most often is: “Does this mean mortgage rates are going down?”

At first glance, it seems like a fair assumption. However, it isn’t correct. In order to understand how mortgage rates are determined, you need to look beyond the Fed. In fact, mortgage rates are influenced by bond markets, inflation, and investor expectations. Therefore, they don’t move in lockstep with Federal Reserve rate cuts.

The Misconception: Fed Cuts Automatically Lower Mortgage Rates

The Fed sets the federal funds rate, which is the short-term interest rate banks charge each other overnight. But importantly, that’s not the same as a 30-year mortgage rate.

While the Fed’s decisions do ripple through the economy, they aren’t the main driver. Instead, how mortgage rates are determined depends more on long-term bond yields and economic expectations than on a single Fed announcement.

How Mortgage Rates Are Determined

To put it simply, mortgage rates reflect the economy’s outlook. Several key factors come into play:

10-Year Treasury Yields

Mortgage rates are closely tied to the yield on the 10-year Treasury bond. As a result, when Treasury yields drop, mortgage rates usually follow.

Investor Demand for Mortgage-Backed Securities

Mortgages are bundled into securities and sold to investors. Consequently, strong demand for these securities can keep rates lower, while weak demand pushes them higher.

Inflation and Economic Data

High inflation leads to higher mortgage rates because investors want protection against the declining value of money. On the other hand, weak economic data can bring rates down.

Risk and Lending Spreads

Lenders also build in extra “spreads” to cover risk, such as borrower credit risk or early loan payoffs. Therefore, these spreads can shift depending on market conditions.

Why Mortgage Rates Are Dropping Now

If the Fed hasn’t cut rates yet, why are mortgage rates easing? The answer lies in three areas:

  • First, slower job growth: A cooling job market signals that the economy is softening.

  • Second, lower inflation pressures: Signs of easing inflation reduce investor fears about long-term rate hikes.

  • Finally, market expectations of Fed cuts: Even before the Fed makes a move, expectations push Treasury yields lower, which pulls mortgage rates down.

This is why today’s mortgage rates are sitting in the mid-6% range—even without an official Fed cut.

What It Means for Buyers and Sellers in Lancaster County

Here in Lancaster County, even a small drop in mortgage rates makes a noticeable difference.

For buyers, this means more purchasing power. Homes in Manheim Township, Hempfield, or closer to downtown Lancaster that might have stretched your budget earlier this year may now fit more comfortably. Moreover, lower rates give buyers more room to negotiate—maybe for upgrades, closing costs, or timing.

 

Sample Mortgage Affordability Chart — Lancaster County

Home Price Down Payment (20%) Loan Amount Monthly Payment @ 7.00% Monthly Payment @ 6.50% Monthly Payment @ 6.00% Monthly Payment @ 5.50%
$300,000 $60,000 $240,000 ~$1,596 ~$1,513 ~$1,430 ~$1,348
$330,000 $66,000 $264,000 ~$1,755 ~$1,664 ~$1,572 ~$1,481
$358,750 (Median Lancaster Co.) (Redfin) ~$71,750 $287,000 ~$1,904 ~$1,805 ~$1,706 ~$1,607
$400,000 $80,000 $320,000 ~$2,123 ~$2,012 ~$1,901 ~$1,790
$450,000 $90,000 $360,000 ~$2,388 ~$2,262 ~$2,136 ~$2,011

Notes & Assumptions:

  • Based on a 30-year fixed mortgage (360 monthly payments)
  • Payments here include principal + interest only (P&I). They do not include property taxes, insurance, mortgage insurance (if <20% down), homeowners association fees, or closing costs. Those add extra monthly cost.
  • Down payment assumed at 20% for simplicity, avoiding Private Mortgage Insurance (PMI).
  • The rate levels chosen (7.00%, 6.50%, 6.00%, 5.50%) reflect what buyers might see in the market depending on credit, market conditions, and lender risk.

What This Chart Shows for Lancaster Buyers

At the median home price (~$358,750 in Lancaster County) (Redfin), dropping from 7.00% to 6.00% means roughly $200/month in savings on principal + interest alone.

In addition, for someone shopping in the $300-$400k range, even a half-point rate drop (from 6.50% to 6.00%) can mean $100-$150+/month savings. That extra room can free up budget for upgrades, closing costs, or simply reduce financial stress.

Sellers benefit too. Indeed, improved affordability means more buyers qualify, which increases bidding competition or helps homes sell more quickly in neighborhoods where $350-$400k homes are common.

For sellers, the impact is just as important. Whenever mortgage rates fall, more qualified buyers are motivated to act. Therefore, this can mean stronger offers on homes in neighborhoods like Willow Street, Mountville, or Lititz. Even modest decreases in rates can expand the buyer pool, making it a great time to list—especially for homes around the median sold price range, which is seeing the most action.

At Chesko & Cavallo Realty Group, we keep a close eye on how mortgage rates are determined because the impact is felt right here in our Lancaster market. After all, a shift in rates can change affordability, competition, and timing for both buyers and sellers.

The Bottom Line

If you’ve ever wondered how mortgage rates are determined, now you know: they’re shaped by Treasury yields, investor demand, inflation, and economic data—not just the Federal Reserve.

Ultimately, the recent rate drops show that mortgage markets move on expectations, not only Fed cuts. Here in Lancaster County, those shifts translate into real opportunities for both buyers and sellers.

👉 Curious how today’s mortgage rates affect your buying power or the value of your home in Lancaster? Then let’s talk. Contact us, and we’ll build a strategy to put this market to work for you.

Further Reading

Freddie Mac – Weekly Mortgage Rate Survey: https://www.freddiemac.com/pmms

Treasury – Daily Treasury Yield Curve Rates: https://home.treasury.gov/resource-center/data-chart-center/interest-rates

Redfin – Lancaster County Housing Market Data: https://www.redfin.com/county/2396/PA/Lancaster-County/housing-market